AN ANALYTICAL STUDY OF SOCIOLINGUISTIC TRANSFER FROM ARABIC TO ENGLISH AMONG THE STUDENTS OF FACULTY OF EDUCATION
Sadek, Rita C.
The failure of the audio-lingual method to foster real communication skills caused language instruction specialists to search for more effective ways to teach foreign languages. This search led to the development of the communicative approach in Britain in the 1970s, which has spread in many parts of the world, Including Egypt, focusing on actively developing the competence of understanding and communicating meaning. According to Canale (1983) and Canale & Swain (1980), communicative competence includes at least four elements, among which is sociolinguistic competence; i.e. the ability to use the language appropriately in different social contexts. Although there are various ways to organize syllabi on a communicative language teaching basis, meaning and context are always central to the learning experience. “This method; communicative method, as its name implies, transforms the traditional non-communicative, teacher-centered classroom into an innovative, communicative, student-centered classroom. “ Oxford (1989). The teacher's role is enriched as he /she becomes more of an advisor, manager, resource person, facilitator, and co- communicator. In this new role, it has become vital for the teacher to have an even better understanding of the learners and the learning strategies they employ. With this in mind, a good deal of research is being done on the interlanguage of learners in a variety of situations. There is a large body of research that claims that transfer plays an important role in shaping interlanguage. The present researcher finds it more logical to start studying such phenomenon; transfer, where the will-be teachers are in mind because classroom discourse represents the main oral input available to the language Learner in the foreign language contexts. There is overwhelming evidence that language transfer is indeed a real and central phenomenon that must be considered in any full account of the foreign language acquisition process. In the face of increasing quantities of foreign language data, researchers have begun to once again focus their attention on language transfer, realizing that “ the baby had been mercilessly thrown out with the bathwater”. The pendulum in recent years has begun to settle, with language transfer being investigated as a phenomenon of importance in and of itself. It has been claimed that language transfer is not only a psycholinguistic process but is often a sociolinguistic process as well, frequently of cultural identity. The current study presents evidence that pragmatic transfer exists in the order, frequency, and content of the linguistic patterns of the Egyptian students’ requests. A pragmatic transfer is the transfer of native language socio-cultural communicative competence in performing foreign language speech acts, where the speaker is trying to achieve a particular function of language. Requests, as speech acts, are interesting from a sociolinguistic point of view because they involve delicate interpersonal interaction and they are important for foreign language educators and others involved in cross-cultural communication. The present research examines the similarities and differences in the realization patterns of the speech Act of requesting between native Egyptian speakers of Arabic and American speakers of English as an analytical approach for tracing sociolinguistic pragmatic transfer. The subjects of this study were 60 native Egyptian Arabic speaking University undergraduate students studying at Benha faculty of education and 60 Native American English speaking undergraduate students at Texas A&M University. The Egyptian subjects were studying English as a foreign language in the English Department to be teachers of English as a foreign language. the data was collected by a controlled elicitation procedure called Discourse Completion Test (DCT). The data were then categorized based on the coding system developed by the Cross-Cultural Speech Act Realization Project (Blum Kulka, House & Kasper 1989). In order to analyze the differences between Arabic as a native language, English as a native language, and English as a foreign language in the realization of linguistic patterns of request, a statistical analysis was performed with request patterns as a dependent variable and language as a grouping variable. Another analysis was performed where frequencies of different components of requestive speech acts were compared between Arabic as a native language, English as a native language, and English as a foreign language. The analysis revealed that there are considerably significant differences between Arabic as a native language and English as a native language, as well as between Arabic as a native language and English as a foreign language. For example, the analysis revealed that Egyptian Arabic subjects are considerably more direct when making requests compared to American subjects. The results also showed that the Egyptian subjects used considerably more alerters, supportive moves, and internal modifiers compared to American subjects. It is suggested that in some languages, like Arabic, speakers may compensate for the level of directness in the requestive speech acts by using more supportive move, alerters and internal modifiers. These differences in requestive speech act realization patterns may cause some cross-cultural communication problems for learners of English as a foreign language. The current study provides evidence that pragmatic transfer from the Arabic language influences the English language of the Egyptian students which warrants further exploration of pragmatic transfer in other areas besides requests. In this sense, the 30 has some pedagogical implications for teaching English as a foreign language. In particular, there appears to be a need to assist Egyptian-speaking learners of English in developing cross-cultural and cross-linguistic awareness concerning the appropriateness of language as well as its correctness.
Texas A& M/Benha Univesity
USA/Egypt
